Well, if you're going to put it like that, a serial killer doesn't really make sense, either... [It'd be pretty silly of Astoria to throw them into a situation where they could all just die immediately before being able to fix anything.

Ren starts heading in the direction of the light, though he hums a little in thought when Sheryl mentions the potential of awful things.] Maybe it's something like an angler fish, luring people in with light...what do you think?

[Okay, now he's just basically telling horror stories.]